Andy Hawbaker Real Estate Reviews
Realtor Reviews for Andy Hawbaker in Windsor, CO
There are plenty of Realtors serving Windsor and the greater Northern Colorado area, but Andy Hawbaker, Realtor® with Coldwell Banker Realty, truly stands out.
Below is a curated collection of real reviews from past clients, shared on Google and Zillow. These testimonials speak to Andy’s dedication, professionalism, and commitment to delivering top-tier service to every client.
Andy has worked hard to earn his reputation as one of Windsor’s most trusted real estate professionals, and it shows.
Have a story to share? We’d love to hear it, drop your own review here!

Realtor Reviews:
“He was always available and consistent. He didn’t give up despite the fact that it took 6 weeks and several different locations as well as contracts on various properties before I was able to get a house I wanted. He made a tenuous and trying time less stressful. Would definitely recommend him and plan on using him next time as well!”
Janice, Fort Collins, CO 2026
“Andy came recommended by our lender and is incredibly helpful, kind, and accessible. He goes out of his way to break down the process, which we appreciated as prospective first-time home buyers, and we never felt pressured or rushed. We would highly recommend working with him!”
Maya, Fort Collins CO 2026
“I would highly recommend working with Andy Hawbaker as your realtor. His expertise, knowledge of the housing market, and laid back attitude made him so easy to work with. Andy helped my partner and I find a house after searching for well over a year and we never felt rushed or pressured into anything. I would absolutely recommend working with Andy!”
Natalie, Mead CO 2026
“My husband and I decided to look at a condo listed on Zillow. Andy replied to our showing request. We didn’t realize then that he would not only become our realtor but also a friend. He took on selling our house plus finding us a new place. Andy always followed up very quickly with a text or phone call anytime we had questions about the buying or selling processing. He was willing to show us many places everytime we asked. We couldn’t recommend him more. He is awesome! Thank you Andy for all your hard work and dedication and all you did for us!
Lyn, Fort Collins 2026
“Working with Andy was honestly such a blessing for my wife and I. From the very beginning, he made us feel protected, supported, and never rushed. He walked us through every step with patience and clarity, making sure we truly understood what we were doing and why. There was never any pressure or persuasion — every decision was ours, and Andy always kept our best interests at the center. He made what could’ve been a stressful process feel calm and safe, and we’re incredibly grateful to have had him in our corner.”
Zane, Johnstown CO 2026
“Andy, was very supportive of our needs, he provided the houses we wanted to view. However, we changed our direction on what we wanted and Andy adapted incredibly. This guy is real, no hidden agenda.”
Jody, Windsor CO 2025
“I worked with Andy on 3 separate real estate transactions over a 6-month period this year…all of this after living in the same place for 25 years. I bought a home in a 55+ community first, then sold the townhome I had lived in for so long and finally, I sold the home that my parents had owned for the last 51 years after they had both passed away. Each transaction brought its own unique set of questions, challenges and emotions. In each transaction, Andy’s concern was that we were doing the best thing for me and that I was comfortable with the decisions we were making. He didn’t push me or try to sway me in any direction but when I asked for advice, he would suggest what he felt was the best option for me. He met me several times on each of my 2 sale transactions to assess what needed to be fixed or touched up and provided recommendations for professionals who could provide the required service. With this assistance, we were able to prepare each home for sale to a point where we had no objections to the inspections whatsoever. What a relief to not have to deal with that hurdle in the process. When it came to pricing, Andy did the necessary research to ensure I was paying or receiving a competitive price. All in all, Andy ran interference every step of the way to make sure all 3 transactions went smoothly, kept me informed of the status of the process and what was coming next and, most importantly, was my dedicated and loyal team mate in getting to the closing table quickly, free of surprises and for my best deal possible. I highly recommend working with Andy Hawbaker-you won’t be disappointed.”
Beth, Longmont, CO 2025
“My partner and I were very fortunate to find Andy. He went above and beyond throughout the entire process of us both buying a new home and selling our existing residence. We never felt pressured or rushed, he maintained the ideal amount of regular communication and was always available when something urgent came up.
Andy was also able to refer us to an excellent mortgage broker, and tapped into his network to refer us to other great folks such as the home inspector and electrician we ended up working with. His knowledge of the market and purchase/sale process was invaluable. We really can’t say enough good things about him, he’ll make sure you’re taken care of!”
Michael, Loveland & Longmont CO 2025
“When we finally decided to start looking, Andy jumped right in. He showed us a ton of houses and was always willing to schedule a showing, no matter how last-minute my requests—usually spurred on by my unhealthy obsession with late-night Zillow searches. He walked us through every step of the process, from figuring out the right timeline to sell our old house to building a smart strategy that helped us win a bidding war on our new one.
Selling our house brought its own set of unique challenges, and Andy handled every curveball with calm and professionalism. He helped us navigate some unusual circumstances, always making sure we understood each option and what to expect. Whether it was dealing with odd inspection results, coordinating tricky logistics, or just answering a million questions, Andy was on top of everything.
Throughout the whole experience, Andy was patient, responsive, and genuinely invested in helping us get the best possible outcome. If you’re looking for someone who’s in it for you—no matter how long it takes or what surprises pop up along the way—I’d recommend Andy without hesitation.”
Katherine, Fort Collins CO 2025
“Andy made selling my townhouse in a competitive market a breeze. He was there to answer every question and step in to immediately solve the inevitable issue that comes up. I can’t recommend Andy highly enough.”
-Chris, Fort Collins, CO 2025
“Andy was an absolute delight to work with. I went into the home buying process full of dread, worried it was going to be a painful process full of pushy people, and Andy showed us that it could be so much better than that. Andy was so nice from the first day we met him, always making sure to point out anything he thought we might not like about a house, because his #1 priority was making sure we found a house we were absolutely in love with. He was always very quick to respond to our emails and get showings set up at times that worked for us. He never made us feel rushed, always assuring us that we’d find the “one” eventually. We felt very comfortable with him being the one walking us through the process and I would buy a home with him again in a heartbeat!”
-Alyssa G., Superior, CO 2025
“Andy went above and beyond. He was so responsive and got us through our first time home buyer experience with all the information we needed and something I expected to be severely stressful felt like a smooth stress free process. I’d highly recommend Andy to first time and experienced homebuyers!”
-Colette Q. Boulder, CO 2025
“As first time home buyers we are endlessly grateful for Andy’s expertise, professionalism, and kindness. Thank YOU, Andy.”
-Kenzie O. Fort Collins, CO 2025
“I am so impressed with the effort Andy Hawbaker put into marketing my home for sale. I knew the marketing effort was critical, and he went above and beyond my lofty expectations. Two open houses (and an offer to do a third!), mailers and beautiful fliers were exceptionally helpful … and reassuring. Andy solicited feedback from realtors who showed my home and shared that freely with me. Moreover, he was exceptionally transparent about the process of selling a home, including his fee. I recommend Andy to friends without hesitation.”
-Juliette R. Fort Collins, CO 2025
“I can’t recommend Andy Hawbaker highly enough for his exceptional work in selling my home in Fort Collins, CO! From day one, Andy went above and beyond, expertly marketing the house to ensure maximum exposure, and coordinating seamlessly with buyers’ agents to get the property under contract quickly. His dedication was clear in every detail! Andy’s guidance and insights were invaluable, as he kept me informed at every stage, educating me on market trends and answering all my questions with patience and expertise. His work ethic and commitment to my success made the experience smooth and stress-free. If you need a real estate agent who truly cares and works tirelessly for your best outcome, Andy is the one to call!”
-Chris H. Fort Collins, CO 2024
“Andy is a great realtor. He communicates well, always answered my calls, and was always on top of what needed to be done. He explained all the caveats with buying/selling our home very thoroughly leaving us without any doubt about how or what our next step should be. His market analysis was spot on too. All in all, I have zero complaints about how our buying/selling process was handled. He did a great job! Anyone looking for a smart, kind, and knowledgeable realtor, I would highly recommend.”
-Beth N. Windsor, CO 2024
“We wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Andy Hawbaker. His dedication to our satisfaction was evident in how he went out of his way to accommodate our schedules and provided honest advice on property values. His efficiency was remarkable. He expedited the paperwork and coordinated viewings effectively. Andy’s marketing background is evident in the way he effectively promoted our home. His strategic marketing led to the sale of our house the first weekend it was on the market. Andy made the selling process so easy and helped us understand what was happening every step of the way. He even had suggestions for places to visit in our new town! Andy went well above and beyond our expectations. We highly recommend Andy Hawbaker!”
Mike O. Windsor, CO 2024
“After speaking with several different realtors, my husband and I decided to go with Andy to sell our home and we are so glad we did. Andy explained the selling process thoroughly and made listing our property easy for us. One caveat was that our home sale coincided with a huge move out of state. With Andy’s guidance, we were able navigate a few delays and still meet our timeline. If you are looking for someone experienced, good-natured, and easy to get along with, Andy Hawbaker is your guy!”
-Brittney B. Severance, CO 2024
“Andy is the greatest! He priced our home right and we got a full price, cash offer after the very first showing! Super easy to work with, knowledgeable, and all around good human.”
-Jenny H. Windsor, CO 2024
“Andy’s professionalism and experience along with his personable and fun personality make him the very best realtor I have ever known! I was so lucky to find him. He is knowledgeable, careful, patient, and wise. He is a truly caring person. He always made time to meet and look at houses, or talk with me about things that came up along the way. His calm demeanor gently guided me through the roller coaster ride of buying a house. I would strongly recommend Andy to anyone who is looking for a realtor. You won’t regret it!”
-Lara L. Evans, CO 2023
“Andy really did help make our second experience with a realtor much better. Buying and selling our home was a breeze, and that’s saying something in today’s housing market. Andy was very thorough and attentive through each and every step of this process. He was assertive, competitive, and an all-around pleasure to work with. (And he made us laugh from time to time as well!) We will absolutely be using Andy if ever we need to buy or sell our home again! We took a chance in a highly competitive market during the slowest part of the season. Now we are in our dream home and we contribute so much of this to Andy’s hard work and determination. We highly recommend Andy for anyone who is even thinking about buying or selling their home. Our process started with a simple conversation just asking what this could look like and what our options were. Andy did the initial consultation for free, worked around our hectic schedule with our toddler, and from the moment we met him we could trust that we were in good hands!”
~Kelsi M. Severance, CO 2023
“We had a great experience with Andy as our realtor. He was patient and attentive to our needs. He found us just the right home in Timnath and we love it. Thanks, Andy.”
~Deb M. Timnath, CO 2023
“Andy did a wonderful job of helping us sell our house long distance! He was very communicative and willing to talk on the phone or zoom when needed. We really appreciate all of his help and knowledge and for making the process feel easy and seamless. Thank you Andy!”
~Kristin C. Loveland, CO 2022
“Our agent, Andy Hawbaker was professional and we feel honest at all times. He arrived the first time as promised, and never made any promises that he could not keep. We would certainly recommend Andy in the future to anyone we know you may be buying or selling a home in the area. Dealing with Andy was a piece of cake can we feel he had our best interests at heart.”
~Vincent F. Longmont, CO 2022
“My time w/ Andy was awesome! I could not believe how fast everything went so smoothly & stress free. Andy was very supportive w/ guidance & support I needed. He was honest to let me know what was good & what was not about the houses we toured. I would recommend Andy to anyone because of his diligence & support. Thank You for all your help”
~Starr L. Berthoud, CO 2022
“Andy is awesome! He is helpful and honest when looking through houses and did a wonderful job explaining the offer contract to us first time homebuyers. I definitely recommend working with Andy!”
~Courtney H. Fort Collins, CO 2021
“So lucky to have found Andy for our home search! He was extremely helpful during the home search process, which can be challenging with today’s market. He went out of his way to find the perfect fit for our needs, would absolutely recommend him to anyone buying/selling in the Denver area.”
~Matthew B. Broomfield, CO 2021
“Andy is both family and a friend. My family and I met Andy back in January of 2021. As first time home buyers, we knew hardly anything about purchasing a home. And with the loan amount we got approved for, we weren’t sure if we were going to find a house that fit our needs. He told us, “I’ll definitely do my best to find you guys a house!” And indeed, Andy followed through and found us exactly what we wanted. He walked with us through the whole process. He was always available whenever we had questions to ask via phone, text, and email and he was always quick to respond. He treated us as if we were his only client. For a first time home buyer, I would definitely recommend Andy.”
~Patrick M. 2021
“Andy did a fantastic job for us after we had a bad experience with another realtor. He stepped up and was responsive to our needs, listened to what we were looking for rather than trying to just get us into a type of home we were not interested in. Even after we had some issues after closing he was still on top of everything to make sure we were taken care of. Overall great experience and would highly recommend him!”
~Jeff D. Livermore, CO 2021
“Andy was great to work with. He is attentive, responsive, and 100% on your team. Buying a home is never easy, but Andy’s good nature, humor, and expertise made it so much more enjoyable. He helped us not just find a house, but our dream house. In this market, that’s pretty special. I would recommend anyone looking for a house, whether it’s your first time or 100th time, reach out to Andy, you won’t be disappointed. As an added bonus, he’s got great “dad jokes” and an awesome positive attitude.”
~Jordan Z. Milliken, CO 2021
“When I first began my home selling/buying journey, I was unable to find a realtor that was familiar with the property I was already wondering about. Andy was the only one who said “Let me find it”. Throughout the selling and purchasing of our new place, we encountered some unexpected road blocks (none of which were his fault!) and every time Andy found a way to solve the problem. He went above and beyond, even after closing, to make sure that everything went smoothly. His intentions and passion for the business clearly exceed financial ones, and it is evident by the experience and success we had in this home buying journey. I’m not sure that we would have been successful if it were not for Andy.”
~Melina N. Windsor, CO 2021
“Andy was immensely patient with our changing requirements (we went from looking for a land lot to looking for a fixer upper). Despite a lower budget and a property that surely was not as lucrative for an agent to assist a client in buying, Andy treated us just like a buyer who was buying a much higher priced home. He met with us and our contractors and inspectors repeatedly to ensure we had all of our boxes checked before closing on the sale.”
-Christa N. Loveland, CO 2021
I want to say thank you to all of my past clients who have trusted my to help them through their home buying or home selling journey. Your reviews and kind words mean everything to me. Receiving these 5 Star Realtor Reviews warms my heart. ~Andy


If you have worked with Andy Hawbaker, Realtor to buy or sell a home in Northern Colorado, please leave a review by clicking the button below. I love helping people buy or sell homes in Windsor, CO or across Northern Colorado. Spread the word so I can help more families with their home buying needs. All reviews on this page have been originally placed on public review platforms including Google and Zillow.
